Notifications
Clear all
General Discussion About The Music Industry
3
Posts
3
Users
0
Reactions
444
Views
Topic starter
21/07/2025 6:09 pm
Hey everyone,
I recently experimented with AI tools like Claude for lyrics and Suno for complete song creation. The result? Two songs — "Detroit Dreamer" and "Fountain of Youth" — were created in under 30 minutes
, with surprising quality and emotional depth.
That got me thinking…
🤖 If I didn’t write a single lyric or play a note, is it still my song?
💬 I’d love to hear your thoughts:
-
Do you think AI-generated songs are truly original?
-
Is it cheating… or just a new kind of artistry?
-
How should credit and ownership work when using tools like Claude or Suno?
-
Could this technology help or hurt real musicians?
-
Have you made music using AI? What was your experience?
🎶 Whether you’re curious, cautious, or already using AI in your workflow — let’s start a healthy conversation.
Drop your thoughts below 👇
Bob
23/07/2025 7:34 pm
I love SUNO! It's fun to mess around and modify lyrics until my heart's content, but it's pricey for the PRO version...like $100 for the year, all upfront. I'd have to make a lot of songs and want the ownership rights, I think. Free version for me. As far as ethics go...I'm cool with just creating songs for myself. I use Ableton for my creations, and I'm not going to change. Real music for real people!
24/07/2025 9:29 am
It’s wild how far we’ve drifted from the human element in music. What used to take years of practice and real-world performance can now be done with a midi keyboard and a few plugins.
I remember when people first got their hands on DAWs—they’d program some MIDI loops and call it a masterpiece. Sure, it technically counts. But could they actually play it live? Doubt it.
Now everything’s pitch-perfect, locked to grid, polished to death. It sounds clean—but where’s the soul?
And now we’ve got AI spitting out entire tracks. No emotion, no life, just pattern-matching.
Use the tools, sure. Just don’t take credit for something you didn’t actually create.
